Turkish Weekly Test(Alpha) Edition:Hisar
 
TreeMenu

EU with Turkey

ISRO Research Centers
  Center for International Security, Terrorism and Ethnic Conflict
  European Union Research Center
  Center for Middle Eastern Studies
  Center for Central Asia and the Caucasus Studies
  International Law Research Center
  Center for Economic Studies
  Center for International Security, Terrorism and Ethnic Conflict

Publications
  Turkish Journal of International Law and Politics
  The Journal of Caucasus and Central Asia
  Review of International Law and Politics


Letters from Europe

by Nermin Aydemir     

   
Consensus Democracies in Deadlock

Have you ever thought why people say the Netherlands; a plural name in defining a unified state and while the Dutch define their own country as “Nederland, not as the Netherlands.  

The answer is hidden in the history of demographical structure of this little country. The Netherlands has always been referred as a country of minorities. When people talk about minorities usually the Turkish or the Moroccan originated people come to mind. Nevertheless, minorities mean more than that in this society.

The “original” Dutch society is actually not constructed by a homogenous group of people, sharing more or less the same basic characteristics of being a nation state. On the contrary, several religious, linguistic, and social cleavages divided the Dutch in distinct pillars by the beginning of the foundation of the country. Dutch people succeeded to overcome these differences and resisted against the Spanish occupation in the 15th century altogether. The Republic of Seven Provinces was founded after the invasion. Although the distinct pillars continued to exist on the mass level, elites succeeded to govern thorough high level of cooperation on the top.  This model is named the “consociational democracy” and the outstanding Dutch politician Lijphard is the one, who made this model prominent in the academic field. The Netherlands is accepted as the peaceful Ireland and it is even seen as a country which could not exist in theory! 

Nevertheless, successful consociational democracies dissolve themselves in time. There is a need for strong elite cooperation for the existence of such a system but pillars disappear at the mass level as things go well between elites. Pillars in the Dutch society became more and more blurred under in time. Moreover, these segments were largely shaped by religious differences and secularization process made divisions between these groups more and more ambiguous. However, the political system stands there with no change.

Even if it sounds good to have consensus on almost all issues on the decision making level, it also brings serious drawbacks. High level of cooperation in decision making strengthens the stability to a considerable extent. However, public loses its interest in politics since it has a very little capability of impact on policies. Things are largely shaped by the consensus between elites, particularly by the three big parties in the Dutch political spectrum. Whoever people vote, the outcome is almost always the same. There is not a real opposition in the Dutch political scene but there are people who oppose the way they are governed. Such conditions create a fertile ground for extreme leaders indeed. Pim Fortuijn was neither a surprise nor a coincidence in this atmosphere. His movement took ground since the country was extremely ready for it. On the other hand, the appearance of the radical leaders in other consensus democracies such as Switzerland, Austria, and Belgium show the dissolving of the consensus democracies.

07 November 2005
Nermin Aydemir is Netherland representative for Journal of Turkish Weekly

  Previous Comments
Advancement within the Immigrant Society: Not an Easy Task to Achieve   2008-11-28 10:00:33
Some Socio-Economic Variables among Migrants in the Netherlands   2008-11-13 01:00:57
Changing Conceptualizations in Security   2008-06-16 16:40:35
Saving the Agenda from Extremists: The Dutch Case   2008-04-02 13:42:24
Anti-Koran Film in the Netherlands: Commonsense Prevails  2008-03-21 17:52:20
Judges in Berlin?   2008-03-07 16:47:00
Germany Capable of Solving Racism?  2008-03-04 18:53:34
Germany Capable of Solving Racism?  2008-03-04 18:46:09
Fire in the German City of Ludwigshafen  2008-02-14 10:41:02
Fire in the German City of Ludwigshafen  2008-02-13 16:42:27
Ashura- The Best Symbol to Describe Multiculturalism in Turkey   2008-01-19 16:20:39
When Parliaments Take over the Place of Courts   2007-10-23 19:45:06
The Immigrant Youth: Shortcomings in Participation   2007-10-10 09:32:06
Voting among the Turkish-Dutch  2007-06-01 11:25:22
The Dual Citizenship Debate in the Netherlands  2007-04-03 18:36:50
To Miss Hilda Darian, My Armenian Reader  2006-12-21 15:08:23
The Armenian Issue in the Netherlands: The removal of the three Turkish-originated MPs from the Candidacy List  2006-10-18 11:21:19
Fundamentalism  2006-07-12 13:46:07
Losing Freedom of Speech  2006-05-05 14:11:37
The New Naturalization Regulations in the Netherlands  2006-03-29 13:56:22
Change in Education Policies in ex-Communist Regimes  2006-03-21 11:20:18
The Identity Issue  2006-03-21 11:18:09
Remarks over Dutch Politics before Municipal Elections  2006-03-21 11:16:01
Naturalization in Germany: Not Easy to Become German  2006-01-26 19:13:11
Immigrant Rebels in France: A Difficult Process of Reconstructing Identities  2005-12-04 11:26:44
Consensus Democracies in Deadlock  2005-11-07 17:35:46
After One Year of the Murder of van Gogh  2005-11-02 13:35:38
Civilizations are Coming Together  2005-10-18 18:04:43
Missing the Humanitarian Values of Europe  2005-08-05 16:33:28
Dutch Multiculturalism in Question: The Case of Ayaan Ali Hirsi  2005-08-05 16:04:04
The Case of Theo van Gogh: Is it the End of Multiculturalism?  2005-08-05 15:58:44
The Dutch Says “Nee” to the Constitution  2005-08-05 15:55:20


Article Types

Editorial

Turkey: Sacrificing 44 Sheep for Obama!
Ihsan Bal

 

One may easily see the breeze of happiness blowing in a global sense from Latin America to the Middle East after the presidential elections in the


Recent Articles
 How Central Asian States Improve Theirties With The Trnc? Possible Strategic Implications And Reactions  Assoc. Prof. Dr. Kamer KASIM
 Atom Egoyan: Life And His Cinema  Sedat Laçiner
 Evolution Of The Idea Of A Permanent International Criminal Court Prior To World War I  Cenap CAKMAK
 Die Schwarzmeerregion – Impetus Für Die Nachbarschaftlichen Beziehungen Der Europäischen Union  Hristofor HRISOSKULOV
 Migration In Eastern Europe And Central Asia  Saltanat Kydyralieva, Istanbul University
 Violence As A Catalyst Or An Obstacle For Peace: The Case Of Sri Lanka  By Bahar BASER, Uppsala University
 Goldhagen Controversy - Hitler's Willing Executioners  Huseyin Akturk

Latest News
 National
  DIARY - Political and General News Events in Turkey
  Russian strategic bombers fly over the Arctic on routine patrol
  Most workers rescued from flooded Chinese coal mine
  100 kg of marijuana seized in Russia's Far East
 Economy
  Let Developing Nations Rule (by Dani Rodrik)
  Has Global Stag-Deflation Arrived? (by Nouriel Roubini)
  Turkey Announces Budget Deficit as 8.3 Bln Ytl in 11 Months
  OPEC Approves Production Cut
 Europe
 
  2009 is Litmus Test for Turkey’s EU Bid
  2008 In Review: Russia, EU See Caspian Energy Dreams Deferred
  Putin Warns Businesses On Excessive Job Cuts
 Central Asia
  Mumbai Hotels Reopen After Terrorist Attacks
  Mullen: 30,000 New Troops In Afghanistan By Summer
  NATO Says Allies Must Follow U.S. In Boosting Afghan Forces
  India test-fires supersonic cruise missile
 Middle East
  PKK frets about Turkish pressure on Northern Iraq Authority
  Iran Calls For Asian Unity
  Iraq Wants Australian Troops Out by the End of the Year
  Iraq Says Iranian Opposition Exiles Must Leave
 World
  Russia denies supplying S-300 missile systems to Iran
  China successfully orbits its 3rd weather satellite
  Russian, U.S. ISS astronauts taking part in spacewalk
  United Nations World Food Programme tie up with Eastern SkyJets
 Balkans
  EULEX Launches, But Devil Is In The Details
  Bosnian Schools Teach Reading, Writing and Division
  Two Bosnian Serbs Indicted Over Wartime Killings
  Bulgarian Railways to Sack Workers over Financial Crisis Effects
 Caucasus
  Nicaraguan president backs Abkhazia, S.Ossetia, plans visit
  New Challenge by OPEC
  Ukranian President in Check
  Belarus 'to recognize Abkhazia, S.Ossetia soon'
 Americas
  Obama unveils task force to help families
  Latin American leaders urge end to U.S. embargo on Cuba
  The Last of the Neo-Cons (by Ian Buruma)
  Obama Picks Dream Green Team